There is nothing like a visit to a toy store, wandering the aisles, and letting your imagination start to run wild. And toy stores aren’t just for kids – many of them now carry vintage toys that may take you down memory lane to the days when you played with My Little Pony, Strawberry Shortcake Dolls, or GI Joes! Not only does a vintage toy store in Cincinnati carry a wide variety of collectible toys, but these three stores are also always on the lookout to add to their collection!
So those old, well-kept toys hanging out in a box in your basement? Bring them in and see if you can sell them to the experts! Whether you are looking to buy or sell, these unique toy stores are waiting to welcome you, and we are lucky to have them so close by!
3 Vintage Toy Stores in Cincinnati to Spark Play & Nostalgia
House of Plastik
The east side of Cincinnati is home to House of Plastik, a vintage toy store specializing in toys from the mid-1970s to the early 1990s! They also carry modern collectibles from various toy lines if you are looking for something a little more contemporary. They are constantly scouring the metro area for exciting finds and love to buy from customers in their stores.
Plus, in addition to their fully stocked toy shelves, they also sell tons of unique candy, including brands that are difficult to find in stores. House of Plastik takes great pride in its extensive collection of Star Wars toys (both new and old), and they have an enormous stock of Funko Pops for every collector.
For a sneak peek of their merchandise, check out their social media, which is constantly updated to reflect what they have in store!
Coolest Toys On Earth
Coolest Toys on Earth sells exactly that! Only the best, most unique, and fun toys will be approved by owner Elliot Werner to make their way onto the shelves of the store (or the pages of the website.) According to their site, “Elliot’s eye for detail, playability, and quality, combined with an ever-lasting imagination, ensures that Coolest Toys On Earth® will intrigue and excite you for many years to come!”
Additionally, they strive to create an environment that will invite your imagination to come alive while making incredible new memories with friends and family. Their “laboratory store” in the eastern Cincinnati area is where they test out their new toys, so you’ll be sure to have a shopping experience you won’t soon forget.
They carry everything from puzzles and fidget spinners to hand puppets, crafts, and outdoor sporting games. When you visit Coolest Toys on Earth, you’ll undoubtedly discover something brand new that you’ve never seen before.
The Toy Department
The Toy Department was founded by four friends in 2018 after they realized their area lacked the presence of a phenomenal toy store. They set out to create a store with the largest selection of high-quality toys in Cincinnati, offered at exceptional prices. As such, they have managed to recreate the same joyful feeling every kid gets walking through a toy store, even for adults.
In 2020, their popularity stretched beyond the containment of their store, and they moved to a larger location in the same shopping center, allowing them to triple their inventory. With decades of experience buying, selling, and collecting toys, their store has been carefully curated to provide Cincinnati with an elite toy experience.
Vintage Toy Store Cincinnati
Whether you are shopping for a kid or yourself, one of these stores will surely have something to delight your imagination. Pay these vintage toy stores in Cincinnati a visit today and see what kinds of treasures you may find!
Ready for more Cincinnati motherhood content? Check out the links below! Then, let’s chat about your dream family session!
